85 Flagged Moving Brokers in 2026: Complaint Data and Patterns
Trunk's database contains 85 moving brokers flagged to avoid, collectively holding 4,549 NCCDB complaints. This is the ranked list, sourced directly from FMCSA records.
What This List Is
Trunk's mover database contains 85 companies registered with FMCSA as brokers only, not carriers, that are flagged to avoid. These are companies with USDOT numbers, FMCSA broker authority, and zero trucks. They take your deposit, then book your move with a carrier you never agreed to.
A company earns flagged status through a combination of factors: NCCDB complaint volume, complaint type (hostage loads, price inflation after pickup, deposit loss), pattern of name changes, and FMCSA enforcement history. The 85 brokers on this list account for 4,549 complaints filed with the National Consumer Complaint Database.
The 15 Most-Complained Brokers
These rankings are drawn directly from NCCDB complaint totals in Trunk's database. All 15 operate under broker-only FMCSA authority.
1. Safe Ship Moving Services (DOT 3475743) | 321 complaints | BBB: F | Florida. The most-complained broker in the database. Safe Ship has an extensive NCCDB record and a BBB F rating, the only broker in the top 15 with a confirmed BBB rating on file. Its complaint profile includes deposit retention and price escalation after pickup.
2. Menards Moving & Storage (DOT 4072455) | 290 complaints | Florida. Subject of a dedicated Trunk investigation. Menards operated out of Florida and accumulated 290 complaints before authority changes. Related investigation: see the Menards company profile.
3. Coastal Moving Services (DOT 4090919) | 229 complaints | Florida. 229 NCCDB complaints. Florida-registered broker with no carrier operations.
4. Eagle Moving Group / New Start Relocation (DOT 3545015) | 179 complaints | Florida. The dual name signals a rebranding attempt while operating on the same DOT. 179 complaints recorded under combined identity.
5. America First Moving Services Inc (DOT 3709259) | 129 complaints | Florida.
6. 3 Brothers Moving & Storage LLC (DOT 3840883) | 111 complaints | Florida.
7. Moving Solutions (DOT 3213737) | 106 complaints | Florida.
8. Swift Shift Van Lines LLC (DOT 4149532) | 98 complaints | Florida. The "Van Lines" suffix is a deliberate misdirection. Swift Shift holds broker authority only.
9. Americas Moving and Storage LLC (DOT 3813986) | 95 complaints | Florida.
10. Allegiance Van Lines LLC (DOT 3507074) | 93 complaints | Florida. Distinct from Allegiance Moving and Storage LLC (DOT 3183105, 55 complaints), which is a separate entity with the same naming strategy.
11. Brightside Moving Group LLC (DOT 4139079) | 84 complaints | Florida.
12. Rapid Relocation (DOT 3570396) | 83 complaints | Florida.
13. Starline Vanlines (DOT 3831389) | 83 complaints | Florida. Another broker using "Vanlines" in the name with no carrier authority.
14. North American Moving Experts LLC (DOT 3929365) | 78 complaints | Florida.
15. United Express Moving and Storage (DOT 4016566) | 76 complaints | Florida.
What These Brokers Have in Common
Of the 85 flagged brokers, 72 are registered in Florida. That is 85% of the list. This concentration is not coincidental. Florida has historically had weaker enforcement against predatory brokers, a dense population of recently-formed LLCs, and proximity to major interstate corridors into the Northeast.
None of the flagged brokers hold carrier authority. They own no trucks, employ no drivers, and are not responsible for your belongings once they hand off the job. Their FMCSA bond requirement is $75,000, which sounds large but covers losses across all consumers who file valid claims simultaneously.
A second pattern: names that sound like carriers. "Van Lines," "Moving & Storage," "Relocation Group" are common suffixes. Swift Shift Van Lines, Starline Vanlines, Allegiance Van Lines, and United Express Moving and Storage all hold broker authority only. The naming is designed to imply truck ownership.
A third pattern: BBB invisibility. Of the 85 flagged brokers, only two have BBB ratings on file in the database: Safe Ship (F) and Gold Standard Moving and Storage (F). The other 83 have no BBB rating recorded. This is consistent with brokers that either never sought accreditation or had it revoked and no longer appear in BBB search results. The absence of a BBB record is not neutral. It removes one of the few public accountability signals that consumers check.
How to Check If Your Mover Is a Broker
Go to the FMCSA Licensing & Insurance page at safer.fmcsa.dot.gov and enter the company's USDOT number. Look for two fields: "Broker" authority and "Common Carrier" authority. If the company shows only broker authority, it will not be driving your truck.
Ask directly: "Do you own the trucks and employ the drivers who will move my belongings?" A broker will often say yes. Follow up by asking for the USDOT number of the actual carrier that will perform the move. Brokers are required by federal law (49 CFR 371.113) to disclose the carrier's identity before your move. If they cannot or will not name the carrier before you pay a deposit, that is a federal regulatory violation.
The FMCSA's NCCDB complaint database (nccdb.fmcsa.dot.gov) is publicly available. Searching a company's DOT number there will show complaints filed by previous customers. A company with more than 10 complaints per 100 moves is a signal worth investigating further. The brokers on this list average 54 complaints each.
Companies Mentioned
Sources: