Data Analysis9 min read

Moving Companies Without Required Insurance on File: What It Means for Your Belongings

FMCSA requires moving companies to maintain specific insurance minimums. Our analysis of 2,231 household goods carriers reveals how many have gaps in their filings.

|Trunk Research
Comment

Three Types of Insurance FMCSA Requires

FMCSA mandates three categories of insurance for companies transporting household goods across state lines. Each protects different parties and covers different risks.

BIPD (Bodily Injury and Property Damage) liability insurance covers third-party injuries and property damage caused by the carrier's vehicles. For household goods motor carriers, the minimum required is $750,000 in BIPD coverage. This is the most critical filing because it protects other drivers, pedestrians, and property owners if the moving truck causes an accident.

Cargo insurance covers damage to the goods being transported. This is separate from the carrier's liability under federal valuation rules (60 cents per pound per article under Released Value, or Full Value Protection). Cargo insurance is the carrier's own policy that backs up their liability to shippers.

Surety bond or trust fund protects consumers who have claims against the carrier. For brokers of household goods, the minimum bond is $75,000. For motor carriers, the bond requirement is separate from BIPD insurance. The bond gives consumers a financial backstop if the carrier refuses to pay a legitimate claim.

The $750,000 vs. $75,000 Gap

One of the most significant differences between carriers and brokers is their insurance requirement. A motor carrier of household goods must maintain at least $750,000 in BIPD coverage. A broker of household goods needs only a $75,000 surety bond.

This 10x difference matters because many companies that advertise as "movers" are actually brokers. They take your booking and your deposit, then dispatch a separate carrier to perform the actual move. If something goes wrong, the broker's $75,000 bond is shared across all pending claims, not reserved for yours alone.

In our database, companies like Safe Ship Moving Services (USDOT 3475743) operate as brokers with zero trucks on file, accumulating 321 total NCCDB complaints from 2023 through 2026. When consumers file damage claims, they discover the broker has limited financial responsibility for the carrier's actions. The carrier that actually moved their goods may be a different company entirely, sometimes one with its own complaint history.

What "No Insurance on File" Actually Means

When FMCSA records show no insurance on file for a carrier, it does not necessarily mean the company has zero insurance. It means they have not filed the required proof of insurance with FMCSA. There are several reasons this happens.

The company may have let their insurance lapse and not renewed. Their insurance provider may have cancelled coverage and filed a cancellation notice with FMCSA. The company may be newly registered and in the process of filing. Or the company may be operating without insurance entirely.

Regardless of the reason, a carrier with no insurance on file with FMCSA should not be operating. FMCSA's system is designed so that insurance filings are a prerequisite for active operating authority. When insurance is cancelled, the carrier's authority should be revoked after a grace period. In practice, enforcement of this requirement has gaps, particularly for small carriers.

Companies With Empty Insurance Filings

Trunk's analysis of FMCSA insurance filings for household goods carriers found companies operating with empty filing records. Coast to Coast Relocations Inc (USDOT 3567195) and Best in the West Moving and Storage (USDOT 2432650) both show empty insurance filing arrays in FMCSA records, yet both are registered as household goods carriers.

Coast to Coast Relocations accumulated 25 NCCDB complaints between 2023 and 2024 before apparently ceasing operations. Their complaint pattern, combined with empty insurance filings, suggests a carrier that was operating without proper financial backing for consumer claims.

Larger van lines like Allied Van Lines (USDOT 76235) maintain extensive insurance filings across multiple categories: broker bonds, motor carrier BIPD, freight forwarder coverage. Their filings show coverage amounts of $5,000,000 in BIPD, far exceeding the $750,000 minimum. The contrast between these well-insured national brands and small carriers with empty filings illustrates the uneven financial protection consumers face depending on which company they hire.

How Insurance Gaps Enable Fraud

Insurance requirements exist to ensure carriers can pay claims. When those requirements are not enforced, it creates an environment where bad actors can collect payment for moves, damage or hold goods hostage, and face no financial consequence.

Consider the broker-carrier chain. A consumer hires Safe Ship Moving Services, a broker. Safe Ship dispatches LoadRans LLC (USDOT 3729978) or another carrier. LoadRans has 12 trucks and 166 NCCDB complaints from 2023 to 2026. If LoadRans damages goods or holds them hostage, the consumer has to determine which entity is liable, then determine whether that entity has sufficient insurance or bond coverage to pay the claim.

KF Moving LLC (USDOT 4260313), which carries a "Not Authorized" status with FMCSA, has been documented delivering loads for other carriers in the same broker-carrier network. A carrier operating without authority almost certainly has no valid insurance on file. Any goods entrusted to this carrier have no FMCSA-mandated financial protection.

How to Verify a Mover's Insurance Before You Book

Checking a mover's insurance status takes less than five minutes and can save you from a financially unprotected move.

Step 1: Get the company's USDOT number. Every legitimate interstate mover has one. If they cannot provide it, do not hire them.

Step 2: Search the USDOT number on FMCSA's SAFER website (safer.fmcsa.dot.gov). Look at the "Insurance" section of the carrier's profile.

Step 3: Verify three things. BIPD insurance should show at least $750,000 on file for a motor carrier. If the company is a broker, they need a $75,000 bond. Check the effective date to confirm the coverage is current, not expired.

Step 4: Confirm the company is a carrier, not a broker. If you want a company that operates its own trucks, look for "Carrier" under Operation Type. If you see "Broker" and zero trucks, understand that a different, unknown company will perform your move.

Step 5: Ask the company directly for their certificate of insurance. Any legitimate carrier can provide this on request from their insurance provider.

Companies Mentioned

Sources: FMCSA SAFER System (safer.fmcsa.dot.gov)FMCSA Insurance Filing Requirements (49 CFR Part 387)Trunk USDOT records database (2,231 HHG carriers analyzed)NCCDB complaint data (National Consumer Complaint Database)

Discussion

Have thoughts on this? Share them below.

Find vetted movers in your area

Trunk cross-references eleven independent sources for every profiled mover. Verified pricing, safety records, community reviews, and fraud pattern detection.

Search movers →

Find movers near you

trunk

trunk.lorea.ai