Original Research10 min

We Scraped 23,065 Moving Carriers from VektorTMS. The Industry Is More Connected Than Anyone Realized.

Every tab. Every connection. Every fraud signal. A three-week scrape of the largest carrier intelligence database in trucking reveals that 2,380 movers share trucks with other companies, 241 revoked carriers are still connected to active networks, 96% have never been safety-rated, and the average mover is linked to 32 other companies.

|Trunk Research
Comment

VektorTMS is the trucking industry's largest carrier intelligence platform. It aggregates FMCSA registration data, roadside inspection records, insurance filings, equipment registrations, and officer networks into per-carrier profiles that freight brokers and shippers use to vet carriers before dispatching loads.

Household goods consumers have no access to this data. Neither, apparently, does FMCSA's own enforcement staff, which conducted zero HHG carrier enforcement cases in FY 2026 and zero new entrant safety audits in five consecutive fiscal years.

Trunk scraped all 8 VektorTMS tabs (overview, safety, authority, equipment, operations, network, identity, reviews) for every mover in our database with a DOT number. The scrape ran from October 10 through November 2026. 23,065 carriers were found with full profiles. 83 were not on VektorTMS (primarily pure brokers with zero trucks). The data is now integrated into Trunk's ontology and rendered on mover profiles.

The Dataset

23,065 carriers scraped. For each, VektorTMS provided:

Overview: Legal name, DOT, MC, address, phone, fleet size, driver count. Safety: Safety rating, out-of-service rates for vehicles and drivers, inspection history. Authority: Operating authority status, insurance (BIPD amount, insurer name), bond status. Equipment: Power units, VIN registrations, equipment shared with other DOTs. Operations: Lanes served, mileage, commodity types. Network: Connected companies (shared VINs, shared officers, shared addresses, shared inspection locations). This is the tab that reveals the industry's hidden structure. Identity: Corporate officers, registered agents, DBA names, DUNS numbers. Reviews: VektorTMS proprietary carrier ratings.

The network tab is the most significant. For every carrier, VektorTMS identifies every other carrier that shares a vehicle identification number, a corporate officer, a physical address, or an inspection record. The result is a connection graph spanning the entire industry.

The Industry's Hidden Connections

The average carrier in our dataset is connected to 32.5 other companies. The most connected carrier has 5,085 connections. 89.7% of carriers (20,702) have 10 or more connections.

These numbers are higher than expected because VektorTMS defines connections broadly. A carrier that was inspected at the same weigh station as another carrier may show a connection. A van line agent that operates under a national van line's DOT will show connections to every other agent in the network. An equipment leasing company's trucks may appear under multiple DOTs.

The challenge is separating signal from noise. Not every connection is suspicious. But the connections that combine multiple signals, shared officers plus inactive authority plus shared VINs, are the signatures of chameleon operations.

See: The 50 Most Connected Moving Companies in America (trunk.lorea.ai/insights/vektor-most-connected-movers)

Nine Fraud Signals, Three That Matter

VektorTMS data, combined with Trunk's analysis, produces nine fraud signal categories. They vary enormously in specificity:

Broad signals (nearly universal, low individual value): - reincarnation_chain: 23,071 companies (99.97%). Connected to an entity that has dissolved or reincarnated. Nearly every carrier has at least one dissolved company in its extended network. - double_broker: 23,046 (99.9%). Connected to entities flagged for double-brokering patterns. - large_network: 23,071 (99.97%). Five or more connections. - owner_group: 16,699 (72.3%). Part of a shared ownership structure.

Moderate signals (common but more targeted): - inactive_authority: 15,018 (65%). Connected to entities with inactive operating authority. - shared_officer: 13,271 (57.4%). Shares a corporate officer with another DOT.

Narrow signals (rare and actionable): - shared_vin: 2,380 (10.3%). Shares actual trucks (VINs) with other DOTs. This means the same physical vehicle has been registered or inspected under multiple carrier numbers. - above_avg_oos: 1,588 (6.9%). Above-average out-of-service rate at roadside inspections. - revoked_in_network: 241 (1.0%). Revoked carrier still connected to active companies through shared officers, equipment, or addresses.

The actionable intelligence is in the narrow signals and in combinations. A company with shared_vin plus shared_officer plus inactive_authority is not a coincidence. It is a chameleon operation.

See: The Largest Suspicious Clusters in the Moving Industry (trunk.lorea.ai/insights/vektor-suspicious-clusters-moving-industry)

2,380 Companies Share Trucks

When the same truck (identified by VIN) appears under multiple DOT numbers, it means one of three things: the truck was sold or transferred between carriers (legitimate), the truck is leased through an equipment pool shared by van line agents (legitimate), or a revoked carrier's truck is now operating under a new DOT without the truck having actually changed hands (chameleon).

10.3% of carriers in our dataset share at least one VIN with another company. The top shared-VIN company (S. Duran's Trucking) is connected to 3,102 other DOTs through equipment sharing. This likely represents a large equipment leasing or van line network rather than fraud.

The actionable subset: companies that share VINs AND have inactive or revoked authority AND share officers with the entity that now operates the same truck. This combination is the textbook chameleon pattern, and it exists in the data.

See: 2,380 Moving Companies Share Trucks With Other Companies (trunk.lorea.ai/insights/vektor-shared-vins-2380-companies)

241 Revoked Carriers Still in Active Networks

Of the 15,018 carriers with inactive authority, 241 are flagged as still connected to active companies through shared officers, equipment, or addresses. These are not former carriers that dissolved and disappeared. They are carriers whose authority was revoked for cause, and whose people and trucks are still operating through connected entities.

This is the definition of a chameleon operation: dissolve one company, continue operating through another, without FMCSA detecting the connection. The SAFE Act (H.R.7539 and S.5150), pending in Congress, would direct FMCSA to build automated tools to detect exactly these connections. The data already exists. VektorTMS has it. Trunk now has it. FMCSA does not use it.

See: 241 Revoked Carriers Are Still Connected to Active Moving Networks (trunk.lorea.ai/insights/vektor-revoked-carriers-in-networks)

96% Have Never Been Safety-Rated

FMCSA assigns safety ratings of Satisfactory, Conditional, or Unsatisfactory based on compliance reviews. Of the 23,065 carriers in our dataset:

Not rated: 22,191 (96.2%) Satisfactory: 666 (2.9%) Conditional: 173 (0.7%) Unsatisfactory: 10 (0.04%)

The 666 Satisfactory-rated carriers are the ones FMCSA has actually reviewed and found compliant. For consumers, a Satisfactory rating is a genuine positive signal. Trunk now displays safety ratings on mover profiles when available.

The 10 Unsatisfactory carriers are still registered in FMCSA's system. The 173 Conditional carriers include some operating large networks (Two Men and a Truck Henry County GA with 395 connections, All My Sons Milwaukee with 125).

But the real finding is the 96%. FMCSA conducted zero HHG new entrant safety audits in five consecutive fiscal years. The rating system exists but is not applied to household goods carriers. A consumer checking a mover's safety rating will find 'Not Rated' 96% of the time, which conveys no information.

See: 10 Moving Companies With Unsatisfactory Safety Ratings (trunk.lorea.ai/insights/vektor-unsatisfactory-safety-ratings)

Cross-Reference: Vektor Signals Meet NCCDB Complaints

The most powerful analysis combines VektorTMS network data with FMCSA complaint data.

SafeShield Moving Services (DOT 4470034), the carrier linked to Safe Ship Moving Services (the most-complained broker in America), has 302 connections in VektorTMS and 6 fraud signals. Safe Ship dispatches consumer moves to SafeShield and other carriers. The consumer has no visibility into which carrier will arrive. Vektor data shows the web of companies that could show up at a consumer's door is 302 entities deep.

Howards Vanlines (DOT 4391903), which accumulated 206 complaints from a single truck in 12 months, is connected to Handle With Care Moving (DOT 3190967, 3x revoked) and JCS Moving (DOT 4526003) through the Eli Hasut operator network. Vektor data confirms these connections through shared officers and equipment.

The companies with the highest NCCDB complaint counts AND the highest Vektor connection counts AND the most fraud signals are the companies FMCSA should be investigating. The data exists to identify them. It is now public.

See: SafeShield Moving Services: 302 Connections (trunk.lorea.ai/insights/vektor-safeshield-302-connections)

What This Data Enables

Before this scrape, the connections between moving companies were invisible to consumers, journalists, and advocates. FMCSA's public tools show one company at a time. VektorTMS is a commercial product designed for freight brokers, not consumers.

Trunk has now integrated this data into the public record:

1. Mover profiles on Trunk display safety ratings (Satisfactory, Conditional, Unsatisfactory) when available. 2. Profiles display network warnings when a mover has concerning signals: connected to revoked carriers, shares trucks with other companies, or has above-average out-of-service rates. 3. The connection count (how many other companies a mover is linked to) is visible on every profile with Vektor data. 4. The six detailed analysis articles linked throughout this piece document specific findings for shared VINs, revoked carriers, safety ratings, network clusters, SafeShield, and suspicious patterns.

The SAFE Act proposes that FMCSA build a system to detect these connections at registration time. Trunk has built a version of that system using publicly available commercial data. The question is not whether the data exists. It does. The question is whether anyone with enforcement authority will use it.

Methodology and Limitations

The scrape ran from October 10 to November 2026. Each carrier was queried across all 8 VektorTMS tabs using multiple URL slug variations (legal name, name without suffix, name without commas). A 1.2-second delay was applied between requests. The scraper saved progress to the database and auto-resumed after connection failures (the Neon database quota was exhausted once during the process).

Limitations:

1. VektorTMS connections include legitimate business relationships. The fraud signals are indicators, not proof. A connection to a revoked carrier does not mean a company is fraudulent. It means the connection warrants investigation.

2. 83 carriers in our database were not found on VektorTMS, primarily pure brokers with zero trucks. VektorTMS indexes carriers based on inspection and equipment data, which brokers lack.

3. The data is a snapshot as of the scrape dates. Connections, authority statuses, and safety ratings change over time.

4. VektorTMS's connection algorithm is proprietary. We cannot verify every connection independently, but spot-checks against FMCSA records and our existing entity link data confirmed accuracy for companies we have independently researched.

Data

VektorTMS Scrape: Dataset Summary

MetricValue
Carriers scraped23,065
Not found on VektorTMS83
Average connections per carrier32.5
Maximum connections5,085
Companies sharing VINs2,380 (10.3%)
Companies sharing officers13,271 (57.4%)
Revoked but still connected241 (1.0%)
Above-average out-of-service rate1,588 (6.9%)
Safety rated (any rating)849 (3.7%)
Never safety-rated22,191 (96.2%)
Scrape periodOctober 10 - November 2026
Data tabs per carrier8 (overview, safety, authority, equipment, operations, network, identity, reviews)

Source:

Fraud Signal Taxonomy: Broad vs Actionable

SignalCount% of CarriersActionability
reincarnation_chain23,07199.97%Low (nearly universal)
double_broker23,04699.9%Low (nearly universal)
large_network (5+)23,07199.97%Low (nearly universal)
very_large_network (10+)20,70289.7%Low (common)
owner_group16,69972.3%Low-Medium
inactive_authority15,01865.0%Medium
shared_officer13,27157.4%Medium
shared_vin2,38010.3%High
above_avg_oos1,5886.9%High
revoked_in_network2411.0%Very High

Source:

Companies Mentioned

Sources: VektorTMS carrier intelligence data (vektortms.com), scraped October 10 - November 2026. 23,065 carriers with full 8-tab profile analysis.FMCSA NCCDB complaint data aggregated by Trunk.FMCSA A&I enforcement data (FY 2022-2026).Trunk entity link ontology (19,283 links across 28,844 movers).SAFE Act (H.R.7539 and S.5150) and REVOKE Act (H.R.10237), pending before Congress.

Related Research

Discussion

Have thoughts on this?

Anonymous

Find vetted movers in your area

Trunk cross-references eleven independent sources for every profiled mover. Verified pricing, safety records, community reviews, and fraud pattern detection.

Search movers →

Find movers near you

trunk

trunk.lorea.ai