Regulatory Analysis6 min

The Michael Garcia Template: One Lawyer's Contract Powers the Florida Broker Industry

All three broker-carrier agreements obtained for the STB petition use the same standardized template from one San Diego attorney. The template has been in circulation since at least 2004, engineering broker control over tariffs, estimates, disputes, and carrier operations across the Florida household goods broker industry.

|Trunk Research|With John H. Vetne
Comment

The Surface Transportation Board petition required obtaining broker-carrier agreements (BCAs) to demonstrate how Florida household goods brokers structure their relationships with carriers. Three BCAs were obtained, covering three different broker-carrier pairs. All three use the same contract template.

The template is titled "Household Goods Interstate Broker-Carrier, 49 CFR Section 375.409 Agreement." The copyright line reads: "Law Office of Michael Garcia (c) 2004 - 2022 All rights reserved. www.michaelgarcialaw.com." Michael Garcia practices from San Diego, California.

This is not a coincidence. It is a standardized legal product distributed across the Florida broker industry. One attorney, operating from the opposite coast, has engineered the contractual infrastructure that governs how brokers retain binding estimate fees, control carrier tariff rates, dictate dispute resolution, and lock carriers into multi-year non-compete agreements.

The Three Documented BCAs

BCA 1: Safe Ship (Vellar Holdings LLC) and Bee Movers LLC. Signed January 15, 2026. Signatories: Roger Vance for Safe Ship, Yurii Kovalenko for Bee Movers. Section 7 compensates the broker at up to 60% of discounted line haul. Section 10 requires the carrier to be bound by the resolution dictated by the broker.

BCA 2: Coastal Moving Services LLC and Cita Van Lines Inc. Signed January 5, 2024. Section 7 compensates the broker at up to 60% of discounted line haul. Same template provisions throughout.

BCA 3: Amerisafe (Nationwide Moving Services Inc) and All Seasons Logistics LLC. Signed June 2023. Section 7 compensates the broker at up to 75% of discounted line haul. Section 4.G gives the broker the "right and authority to make any tariff rate adjustments." Section 4.I prohibits the carrier from ever issuing an onsite new estimate without first consulting the broker. Section 10 binds the carrier to resolutions dictated by the broker.

The Amerisafe and Eagle BCAs were obtained through 49 CFR 371.115 requests, which give carriers the right to inspect broker transaction records. These were voluntary productions in response to lawful requests, not court-compelled disclosures.

The Amerisafe agreement is the most aggressive of the three, with a 75% commission rate and explicit tariff control language. But all three share the same structural provisions. The template is consistent. Only the percentages vary.

A note on Amerisafe: the company has been engaged in discussions about compliance reform and appears to understand the tariff control issue. Amerisafe's willingness to produce its BCA and to address the problem distinguishes it from brokers that treat regulatory obligations with contempt. The challenge is structural: a broker that unilaterally disarms by eliminating tariff control provisions, reducing commissions, or publishing transparent pricing puts itself at a competitive disadvantage against brokers that do not comply. Regulation reform, not voluntary compliance, is what produces universal disarmament.

Key Structural Provisions Across All Three Templates

Section 3: The broker receives all binding estimate fees, deposits, and advance payments. The carrier collects only the remaining balance as COD at delivery.

Section 4.B: The carrier must deliver upon 110% of a non-binding estimate or 100% of a binding estimate, "or upon determination by BROKER of CARRIER's non-compliance." The broker, not the carrier, decides whether the carrier has complied.

Section 4.G: The carrier charges by cubic feet or weight, subject to governing tariff. The carrier adopts the broker's estimate as its own. The broker has the right and authority to make tariff rate adjustments, and such determination is binding on the carrier.

Section 4.I: The carrier may never issue an onsite new estimate without first consulting the broker. This means that when the carrier arrives at the consumer's home and finds the shipment is larger than estimated, the carrier cannot adjust the price independently. The carrier must call the broker.

Section 4.J: The carrier must never place a consumer's property into storage without providing the broker with the storage facility contact information.

Section 4.K: The carrier must promptly reimburse the broker for any claims or refunds the broker pays on the carrier's behalf.

Section 8: The carrier may only use interline agents or sub-contractors that have been pre-approved by the broker.

Section 9: If the carrier fails to perform, the carrier pays the broker its entire binding estimate fee plus 20% of the discounted line haul. This is the penalty for non-performance, and it flows to the broker, not the consumer.

Section 10: The carrier agrees to be bound by and comply with the resolution dictated by the broker for any dispute. The broker controls dispute resolution.

Section 13: The carrier pays $50 per day for delay issues. The carrier's maximum liability is based on the valuation option selected by the consumer.

Section 15: Non-solicitation. The carrier cannot service, contract, book, or profit from any customer who first canceled a job booked by the broker. The penalty is the binding estimate fee plus 20% of line haul.

Section 16: Six-year non-compete. The carrier cannot work for any other broker or accept household goods shipments from any other broker for six years after the relationship ends.

Part A: The Broker as Consumer's Agent

Part A of the Garcia template states: "An interstate broker acts as the agent of the consumer shipper."

This is legally significant. The template itself acknowledges that the broker is the consumer's agent. Yet the BCA provisions give the broker control over the carrier's tariff, estimates, dispute resolution, and storage decisions. The consumer never sees any of this. The consumer does not know their "agent" has contracted for 60% to 75% of the line haul charges, retained the entire binding estimate fee, and taken authority over the carrier's tariff rates.

An agent who takes 60% to 75% of the transaction value while controlling the service provider's pricing, then keeps that arrangement hidden from the principal, is not acting as an agent in any meaningful sense. The template acknowledges the legal theory while constructing arrangements that contradict it.

Garcia's Dual Role: BCAs and Tariffs

Michael Garcia does not only write broker-carrier agreements. He also prepares the carrier tariffs that the BCAs reference.

In Vetne v. Home & Office Movers (STB Docket No. NOR 42182), the verified complaint at page 12, footnote 5, identifies Garcia as the attorney who prepared the tariff for Home & Office Movers. So the same attorney writes the BCA that gives the broker authority to adjust tariff rates and also writes the tariff that the BCA references.

This means Garcia controls both sides of the contractual chain. The tariff sets the carrier's published rates. The BCA gives the broker authority to adjust those rates. Both documents come from the same law office. The carrier's tariff is not an independent document reflecting the carrier's own pricing decisions. It is part of an integrated package designed by one attorney to serve broker interests.

The broker-initiated tariff modification problem extends beyond the BCA itself. The "tariff log" addendum, which records broker-initiated changes to carrier tariff rates on a per-transaction basis, appears not only in the Amerisafe BCA but also in the tariffs of Safe Ship and other carriers. The tariff itself contains provisions authorizing the broker to modify it. Electronic tariff publication would make these modifications visible. Currently, neither the consumer nor any regulator can see that the carrier's tariff has been adjusted by a broker for a specific transaction.

Significance for the STB Petition

The Garcia template matters for the STB petition in four ways.

First, the BCA is not ad hoc. Three different broker-carrier pairs, operating across different years (2023, 2024, 2026), all use the same template. This is an industry-wide contractual standard, not a one-off arrangement. The provisions are systematic.

Second, one attorney in San Diego is engineering the contractual structure that enables binding estimate fee retention, tariff control by brokers, and dispute resolution control. The industry's contractual infrastructure runs through a single law office.

Third, the template's provisions are designed to maximize broker control while minimizing broker liability. The broker keeps the fees, controls the tariff, dictates dispute outcomes, and locks carriers into six-year non-competes. The carrier bears the operational risk, the liability for delays and damage, and the obligation to reimburse the broker for claims.

Fourth, electronic tariff publication would expose the gap between what the BCA authorizes (the broker controls the tariff) and what the tariff actually says. If tariffs were publicly accessible, consumers and regulators could compare the carrier's published rates to the broker's estimates and see the spread. The Garcia template depends on tariff opacity. Transparency would undermine the entire structure.

Data

Three BCAs Compared: Garcia Template Provisions

ProvisionSafe Ship / Bee Movers (Jan 2026)Coastal / Cita Van Lines (Jan 2024)Amerisafe / All Seasons (Jun 2023)
Commission rate (Section 7)Up to 60% of discounted line haulUp to 60% of discounted line haulUp to 75% of discounted line haul
BEF retention (Section 3)Broker retains all BEF, deposits, advance paymentsBroker retains all BEF, deposits, advance paymentsBroker retains all BEF, deposits, advance payments
Tariff control (Section 4.G)Broker has right to make tariff rate adjustmentsBroker has right to make tariff rate adjustmentsBroker has right to make tariff rate adjustments
Estimate control (Section 4.I)Carrier may not issue onsite estimate without consulting brokerCarrier may not issue onsite estimate without consulting brokerCarrier may not issue onsite estimate without consulting broker
Dispute resolution (Section 10)Carrier bound by resolution dictated by brokerCarrier bound by resolution dictated by brokerCarrier bound by resolution dictated by broker
Non-compete (Section 16)Six-year non-compete with all other brokersSix-year non-compete with all other brokersSix-year non-compete with all other brokers
Non-performance penalty (Section 9)Entire BEF plus 20% of discounted line haulEntire BEF plus 20% of discounted line haulEntire BEF plus 20% of discounted line haul
Non-solicitation penalty (Section 15)BEF plus 20% of line haulBEF plus 20% of line haulBEF plus 20% of line haul

Source:

Companies Mentioned

Contributors: John H. Vetne

Sources: STB petition exhibits (Ex. J): Safe Ship/Bee Movers BCA (January 15, 2026), Coastal/Cita Van Lines BCA (January 5, 2024), Amerisafe/All Seasons Logistics BCA (June 2023). Vetne v. Home & Office Movers, STB Docket No. NOR 42182, verified complaint p. 12, fn. 5. Vellar Holdings LLC v. Bee Movers (August 4, 2026). Garcia template copyright: Law Office of Michael Garcia (c) 2004-2022.

Related Research

Discussion

Have thoughts on this?

Anonymous

Find vetted movers in your area

Trunk cross-references eleven independent sources for every profiled mover. Verified pricing, safety records, community reviews, and fraud pattern detection.

Search movers →

Find movers near you

trunk

trunk.lorea.ai