From Tariff to Estimate to Bill of Lading: The Chain of Documents That Should Protect You (and Doesn't)
Federal law requires movers to publish tariffs, base estimates on those tariffs, and charge only tariff-authorized rates. In practice, consumers never see the tariff, estimates contain charges not in any tariff, and final bills bear no verifiable relationship to published rates. Here is how the chain breaks at every link.
Every interstate household goods move is supposed to follow a chain of documents: the carrier publishes a tariff containing its rates. The estimate is based on that tariff. The bill of lading references the tariff. The final charges match the tariff. If any link breaks, the consumer has a verifiable discrepancy and a basis for a complaint or claim.
In practice, every link is broken. Tariffs are invisible. Estimates contain invented charges. Bills of lading arrive on moving day. Final charges bear no verifiable relationship to any published rate schedule. The consumer has no document to check against, no baseline to dispute from, and no evidence to file with.
Link 1: The Tariff (Invisible)
Federal law requires every HHG carrier to publish and maintain a tariff containing 'all of the rates, charges, and service terms' for its services (49 U.S.C. 13702, 49 CFR 1310.3). The tariff must be arranged to allow determination of 'the exact rate, charges and service terms applicable to any given shipment.'
In practice, tariffs are functionally invisible. They are not filed with any agency. They are not published online. They are theoretically 'available for inspection' on request (49 U.S.C. 13702(c)), but the request process takes up to 20 days (49 CFR 1310.5), and many carriers refuse entirely.
Documented tariff refusals:
In Vetne v. Eagle Moving Group (FMCSA-2026-0069), the complainant requested the carrier's tariff. The broker refused.
In Griffin v. Menards (FMCSA-2026-2971), the complainant requested the tariff and broker-carrier agreement under 49 CFR 371.109 and 371.115. Menards refused.
Noble Moving responded to a tariff request: 'Please be advised that our internal tariff listing is not provided to clients.'
If the consumer cannot see the tariff, the consumer cannot verify the estimate. The chain breaks at the first link.
Link 2: The Estimate (Disconnected from Tariff)
Federal law requires that all rates and charges be based on the carrier's published tariff (49 CFR 375.215, 1310.3). Brokers providing estimates on behalf of carriers must use the carrier's tariff (49 CFR 371.113, 375.409).
In documented estimates reviewed by Trunk, the following charges appear routinely but are almost certainly not contained in any tariff:
Random 'tariff discounts' (24.6%, 25.74%, 28.21%, 28.81%, 31.24%, 42.68%, 49.33%, 52.11%, 53.04%, 63.71%, 67.72%, 70.28%). These fabricated percentage discounts create the illusion of a deal on an inflated base rate.
'Coupon' discounts, 'book now' discounts, 'health care/AAA/first responder/military' discounts, and 'manager discounts.' None of these are standard tariff provisions.
Binding estimate fees of 83% to 119% of the basic transportation cost. In the Eagle case, the BEF exceeded the actual transportation charge.
Origin/destination fees (Menards: $3,024) that function identically to binding estimate fees under a different name.
Full Value Protection charges ranging from $0.00 (Pattern A) to 20% of cargo value (Pattern C), when the industry standard documented by the Federal Register is 1-2% (68 FR 35064).
If these charges are not in the carrier's tariff, they are tariff violations. If there is no published tariff to check against, the violations are undetectable. The chain breaks at the second link.
Link 3: The QA Call (Tariff-Free Price Inflation)
A common broker practice involves a 'quality assurance' or 'logistics' call placed to the consumer 24-72 hours before the move. During this call, the broker re-inventories the goods and presents a revised estimate, typically significantly higher than the original.
The revised estimate is not based on any tariff. It is calculated to maximize broker revenue. The consumer, who has already paid a deposit, cancelled a lease, packed belongings, and committed to a moving date, is presented with a take-it-or-leave-it price increase.
In Griffin v. Menards, the binding estimate of $4,895.11 for 813 cubic feet became a carrier invoice of $7,264.50 for 1,400 cubic feet. In Vetne v. Eagle, the original $4,727 estimate became $14,299 on moving day.
If the carrier's tariff were published electronically, the consumer could verify during the QA call whether the revised charges correspond to tariff-authorized rates. Currently, there is nothing to check against. The chain has no link to hold.
Link 4: The Bill of Lading (Too Late)
The bill of lading is the contract between the consumer and the carrier. It should reference the tariff and contain the final charges. Under 49 CFR 375.505, the carrier must provide the BOL before loading.
In practice, bills of lading arrive on moving day, often after loading has begun. In Griffin v. Menards, the driver did not provide a BOL, inventory list, or any documentation before driving away with the consumer's goods. In Vetne v. Eagle, the complainant did not receive a copy of the revised BOL from the carrier.
By the time the consumer sees the BOL, belongings are on the truck. The consumer's leverage is gone. The STB's 2012 RR Decision recognized this problem, requiring the Valuation Statement to be placed on the BOL (the last document) to 'maximize the time for the customer to learn about, and choose between, the 2 liability options... right up until the time that their shipments are loaded onto a moving van.'
But the BOL cannot serve its protective function if the tariff it should reference is invisible. The chain breaks at the fourth link.
Link 5: Final Charges (Unverifiable)
After delivery, the consumer receives final charges. Under the tariff system, these charges should reconcile with the published tariff. The consumer should be able to verify that the base rate, fuel surcharge, packing charges, valuation charges, and accessorial fees all match the tariff that governed the transaction.
No consumer can do this because no consumer has the tariff. The 180-day billing dispute deadline (49 U.S.C. 13710(a)(3)(B)) begins running from receipt of the BOL, but most consumers do not know the deadline exists, and they have no tariff to dispute against.
The result: a consumer who was charged $14,299 for a move estimated at $4,727 has no document showing whether any of those charges are tariff-authorized. The consumer can file a complaint, but the complaint is the consumer's word against the carrier's undisclosed tariff. The chain breaks at the final link.
What Electronic Tariff Publication Would Fix
If HHG carrier tariffs were published electronically (as water carrier tariffs have been since 2019, and ocean shipping tariffs since 2024), three things change:
1. Price verification. A consumer can compare each line item on the estimate against the published tariff before paying a deposit. A binding estimate fee of 119% of the basic price is verifiable as either tariff-authorized or not.
2. Evidence preservation. A published tariff with an effective date creates a time-stamped record. If the consumer is charged amounts not in the tariff, the published version becomes evidence in a dispute, complaint, or 14704(c) adjudication.
3. Deterrence. A carrier whose tariff is publicly visible is less likely to charge rates not in that tariff. FMCSA A&I data shows tariff pricing violations in 27-34% of HHG safety investigations every year from FY 2022 to FY 2026. Invisible tariffs enable invisible noncompliance.
A Tariff-to-Estimate disclosure requirement would complete the chain: every estimate identifies the carrier, the tariff URL, and the tariff effective date. The consumer clicks through from estimate to tariff and verifies. The chain becomes checkable at every link.
A petition for rulemaking to require electronic tariff publication for HHG carriers is pending before the Surface Transportation Board.
Data
The Document Chain: What Should Happen vs What Actually Happens
| Document | What Should Happen | What Actually Happens |
|---|---|---|
| Tariff | Published with all rates and charges | Invisible, refused on request |
| Estimate | Based on carrier's published tariff | Contains invented charges not in any tariff |
| QA Call | Revisions based on tariff rates | Price inflation with no tariff basis |
| Bill of Lading | References tariff, provided before loading | Arrives on moving day, often after loading |
| Final Charges | Reconcile with published tariff | Unverifiable, no tariff to check against |
| Consumer Remedy | Dispute against published rates | Word against undisclosed tariff |
Source:
Sources: 49 U.S.C. 13702 (tariff requirements). 49 CFR 1310.3 (tariff content). 49 CFR 1310.4-1310.5 (tariff access).49 CFR 375.215 (rates based on tariff). 49 CFR 371.113, 375.409 (broker estimate requirements).49 CFR 375.505 (bill of lading requirements). 49 U.S.C. 13710(a)(3)(B) (180-day billing dispute deadline).STB Released Rates Decision, Docket No. RR 999 (Amendment No. 5), January 10, 2012.STB Water Carrier Tariff Filing Procedures, 84 Fed. Reg. 20292 (May 9, 2019).FMC electronic tariff requirement, 89 FR 25 (Jan. 2, 2024).Vetne v. Eagle Moving Group (FMCSA-2026-0069). Griffin v. Menards (FMCSA-2026-2971).FMCSA A&I enforcement data (FY 2022-2026): tariff pricing violations in 27-34% of HHG investigations.Documented estimates: Safe Ship, Amerisafe, Eagle/New Start, Menards, DA Moving/Graceful. Published on Trunk.