What's Inside a Broker-Carrier Agreement: The Document That Proves the Consumer's Deposit Isn't Paying for the Move
Broker-Carrier Agreements are the contracts between HHG brokers and the carriers they dispatch. Consumers never see them. Court filings and settlement documents have exposed what they contain, and what they reveal is that the deposit you paid is not going to the company that moves your furniture.
When you hire a moving broker, you sign an estimate and pay a deposit. You assume the deposit is a down payment on your move, that it flows to the company that will load your furniture onto a truck, drive it across the country, and deliver it to your new home.
It does not.
The document that proves this is called a Broker-Carrier Agreement, or BCA. It is the contract between the broker and the motor carrier the broker dispatches to perform the actual move. The consumer is not a party to this contract. The consumer does not see it. The consumer does not know it exists.
BCAs are treated as proprietary business documents. Brokers classify them as trade secrets and enforce confidentiality clauses against carriers who might disclose the terms. The only time these agreements become visible to the public is when they surface in court filings, regulatory complaints, or settlement exhibits.
Two BCAs have now been entered into public records. Together, they document the same structural problem: the consumer's deposit stays with the broker. The carrier arrives on moving day having been paid nothing.
What the BCAs Reveal
Safe Ship Moving Services BCA (Vellar Holdings v. Bee Movers, August 4, 2026)
This broker-carrier agreement was filed as an exhibit in Vellar Holdings LLC v. Bee Movers, a court action initiated in August 2026. Section 3 of the agreement confirms that the binding estimate fee (BEF), the deposit the consumer pays at booking, goes entirely to the broker. None of it is remitted to the carrier.
The carrier receives 40% or less of the discounted line haul charge. The broker retains all BEF revenue plus up to 60% of the line haul amount. The entity that provides "price certainty" to the consumer keeps the fee. The entity that actually loads, transports, and delivers the shipment absorbs weight overages, damage claims, and delivery logistics with no share of the BEF.
On a $7,000 consumer estimate with a $2,500 BEF and $4,500 line haul, this means: Safe Ship keeps $2,500 (BEF) plus $2,700 (60% of line haul) = $5,200. The carrier who does all the physical work receives $1,800.
Eagle Moving Group / Home & Office BCA (Vetne v. Eagle, FMCSA-2026-0069)
This broker-carrier agreement was entered as an exhibit in a complaint filed with FMCSA. Section 7 sets Eagle's broker compensation at "15 percent of the discounted line haul charges." That figure, 15%, sounds modest. It is not the full picture.
Eagle collected $3,805 in deposits from the consumer. Eagle remitted none of that money to the carrier, Home & Office. The carrier arrived on moving day having been paid zero dollars. Eagle's 15% commission came on top of the deposit retention, not instead of it.
The consumer paid $3,805 before the truck arrived. The carrier saw none of it. The carrier's only path to revenue was to collect the remaining balance directly from the consumer on moving day.
Where the Money Actually Goes
The deposit flow in a brokered move follows a consistent pattern across every documented BCA.
Step 1: The consumer receives a binding estimate. The estimate shows a total price (for example, $8,000) and requires a deposit (for example, $3,200, which is 40% of the total).
Step 2: The consumer pays the deposit to the broker. The consumer believes this is a payment toward the move.
Step 3: The broker retains the entire deposit. The BCA designates this as the broker's binding estimate fee and/or commission. No portion is forwarded to the carrier.
Step 4: The broker dispatches a carrier. The carrier agrees to perform the move for a fraction of the line haul charge (40-85% goes to the broker, depending on the BCA terms).
Step 5: The carrier arrives on moving day. The carrier has received no money. The carrier must collect from the consumer directly to cover the cost of performing the move.
Step 6: The consumer is told the remaining balance is due in cash or money order. If the carrier's actual costs exceed what the broker's discounted rate covers, the carrier has a financial incentive to revise the estimate upward.
The consumer paid $3,200 already. The carrier received $0 of it. The consumer now owes the carrier the full cost of the actual move. The deposit did not reduce the consumer's total obligation to the carrier. It was a separate payment to a separate company for a separate service: brokerage.
Why This Causes Moving Day Price Inflation
The BCA structure creates a predictable economic incentive for moving day price increases.
The carrier accepted the job at a discounted rate. The broker kept 15% to 60% of the line haul plus the entire deposit. The carrier must now perform a labor-intensive, multi-day service (loading, transit, delivery) for whatever fraction remains.
If the carrier's actual costs (labor, fuel, tolls, equipment) exceed the discounted rate, the carrier has two options: absorb the loss, or revise the estimate on moving day.
Revising the estimate is straightforward. The carrier can claim the shipment weighs more than estimated, occupies more cubic feet than quoted, requires additional packing, includes items not on the original inventory, or needs shuttle service at the destination. Some of these revisions are legitimate. Many are not. But the economic pressure to revise is built into the BCA itself.
Consider the Eagle/Home & Office example. Eagle collected $3,805 from the consumer. Eagle kept all of it. Home & Office arrived to perform a move for which they had been paid nothing. Home & Office needed to collect enough from the consumer to cover their actual costs plus a margin. The consumer, whose furniture was now on the truck, had limited bargaining power.
This is not a failure of individual bad actors. It is the structural result of a contract that separates the entity that collects the consumer's money from the entity that performs the service. The BCA is the mechanism that makes moving day price inflation rational for the carrier.
What Consumers Should Know
First, your deposit is not a down payment on your move. When you pay a deposit to a broker, you are paying for brokerage services. The company that loads your furniture has not received any of that money. This is documented in every BCA that has been entered into public records.
Second, ask one question before signing: "Will the company I am paying also be the company that loads my furniture onto the truck?" If the answer is no, you are hiring a broker. The deposit stays with the broker. The carrier arrives separately.
Third, 49 CFR 371.3(c) gives carriers the right to inspect broker transaction records. This regulation exists so carriers can verify what the broker charged the consumer versus what they received. In practice, brokers use confidentiality clauses to block access to these records. But the regulation is on the books.
Fourth, if your price increases on moving day, understand the economics. The carrier may be inflating charges, but the carrier may also be trying to recover the revenue that the broker already took. Neither scenario benefits the consumer. Both scenarios are a direct consequence of the BCA structure.
Fifth, a carrier-direct move eliminates this problem entirely. When you hire a motor carrier directly (not through a broker), 100% of your payment goes to the company performing the move. There is no BCA. There is no hidden fee split. There is no second company arriving on moving day that has never seen a dollar of your deposit.
Data
Deposit Flow in a Brokered Move: Where the Money Goes
| Payment Event | Consumer Pays | Broker Receives | Carrier Receives |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deposit at booking (Safe Ship example, $7,000 estimate) | $2,500 BEF deposit | $2,500 (100% of deposit) | $0 |
| Line haul commission (Safe Ship, 60% broker retention) | (included in total) | $2,700 (60% of $4,500 line haul) | $1,800 (40% of line haul) |
| Total on Safe Ship example | $7,000 | $5,200 (74%) | $1,800 (26%) |
| Deposit at booking (Eagle example) | $3,805 | $3,805 (100% of deposit) | $0 |
| Line haul commission (Eagle, 15% broker retention) | (included in total) | 15% of discounted line haul | 85% of discounted line haul |
| Moving day balance (Eagle) | Remaining balance due in cash/money order | $0 additional | Full remaining balance from consumer |
Source:
Companies Mentioned
Contributors: John H. Vetne
Sources: Vellar Holdings LLC v. Bee Movers (August 4, 2026), broker-carrier agreement exhibit. Vetne v. Eagle Moving Group (FMCSA-2026-0069), complaint exhibits including broker-carrier agreement. 49 CFR 371.3(c) (broker transaction record transparency rule).