Zero Shipper Reviews in Five Years: The FMCSA Investigation Tool Nobody Uses
FMCSA's A&I enforcement system includes a specific investigation type called 'Shipper Reviews' designed to verify consumer experiences with household goods carriers. It has been used exactly zero times across FY 2022 through FY 2026. While 44,864 complaints accumulated in the NCCDB and estimate fraud remained the top complaint category, the one tool built to investigate the consumer side of HHG transactions was never deployed.
FMCSA's Analysis and Information (A&I) system categorizes safety investigations into several types. Most are carrier-facing: CSA investigations (onsite comprehensive, onsite focused, offsite) examine the carrier's records, operations, and compliance. Terminal investigations visit a carrier's physical facility. Non-Rated Reviews assess carriers that have not yet received a safety rating.
But one investigation type is designed to examine the other side of the transaction: the Shipper Review.
A shipper review involves FMCSA investigators contacting consumers, reviewing their estimates, bills of lading, and comparing those documents against the carrier's tariff and published rates. It is the only investigation type that centers the consumer's experience rather than the carrier's paperwork.
According to FMCSA's own A&I Safety Investigations By Type report, filtered to Household Goods carriers, this tool has been used zero times in five fiscal years.
The Data: HHG Safety Investigations by Type, FY 2022 to FY 2026
The following table shows every investigation type and its usage count for HHG carriers across five fiscal years. Data source: FMCSA A&I Safety Investigations By Type, Carrier Type: Household Goods, snapshot 9/25/2026 (STB petition Ex. E-1).
| Investigation Type | FY 2022 | FY 2023 | FY 2024 | FY 2025 | FY 2026 | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Total Investigations | 159 | 176 | 135 | 192 | 106 | | CSA Investigations | 103 | 116 | 104 | 140 | 79 | | Onsite Comprehensive | 35 | 38 | 56 | 52 | 36 | | Onsite Focused | 65 | 52 | 42 | 65 | 43 | | Offsite | 3 | 1 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | Cargo Tank Facility Reviews | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | | Shipper Reviews | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | | Non-Rated Reviews | 59 | 60 | 31 | 52 | 27 | | Security Contact Reviews | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | Terminal Investigations | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 |
Two investigation types recorded zero usage across all five years: Cargo Tank Facility Reviews and Shipper Reviews. Cargo Tank reviews are irrelevant to household goods carriers. They exist in the system because the same A&I framework covers hazmat and tanker carriers.
Shipper Reviews are not irrelevant. They are the investigation type specifically designed for consumer-side verification in household goods transactions. And they have never been used.
What Other Investigation Types Accomplished
The contrast with other investigation types makes the gap visible.
In FY 2026 alone, FMCSA conducted 79 CSA investigations of HHG carriers. These are carrier-facing inspections: investigators review the carrier's safety management systems, driver files, vehicle maintenance records, and regulatory compliance documentation. They generated findings. They identified violations. CSA investigations work.
Non-Rated Reviews accounted for 27 investigations in FY 2026. These target newly authorized carriers that have not yet been rated, assessing whether they meet minimum safety standards. Even Terminal Investigations, which require a physical visit to a carrier's facility, were conducted twice in FY 2026.
Every investigation type that has any conceivable application to HHG carriers was used at least once. Except the one designed to verify what consumers actually experienced.
44,864 Complaints. Zero Shipper Reviews.
Between calendar years 2021 and October 2026, consumers filed approximately 44,864 complaints about moving companies through FMCSA's National Consumer Complaint Database (NCCDB).
Estimates/Final Charges is the number one complaint category at 19.8% of all HHG complaints. These are consumers reporting that the amount they were charged did not match the estimate they received. Tariff violations are the second most common finding when FMCSA investigators actually examine carrier records.
A shipper review is the investigation type designed to verify exactly this: compare the consumer's estimate against the carrier's tariff and published rates. It would generate direct evidence of whether the carrier's charges matched the tariff, whether the estimate was prepared in accordance with regulatory requirements, whether the bill of lading matched the estimate, and whether required consumer protection documents were provided.
The complaints exist by the tens of thousands. The investigation tool exists in the system. The connection between them has never been made. Not once in five years.
What 50 Shipper Reviews Per Year Could Reveal
If FMCSA conducted even 50 shipper reviews per year, selecting from the top-complained carriers in the NCCDB, investigators would contact consumers who filed complaints, collect their estimates and bills of lading, and compare those documents against the carrier's tariff.
This would generate evidence of tariff violations (carrier charged rates not in its tariff), binding estimate fraud (BEF overcharges where the final bill exceeded a binding estimate), full value protection waiver patterns (carriers systematically steering consumers away from adequate insurance coverage), and estimate-to-final-bill inflation (the gap between what consumers were quoted and what they were charged).
Fifty reviews per year would represent less than half the volume of Non-Rated Reviews already being conducted. The investigative infrastructure exists. The staff exists. The complaint pool to select from is enormous. The tool sits unused.
Electronic Tariff Publication Would Make Shipper Reviews Effective
There is a structural reason shipper reviews would be difficult today, even if FMCSA chose to conduct them. HHG carrier tariffs are not published electronically.
Under current regulations (49 CFR 1310.5), a carrier's tariff must be made available upon request, but the carrier has up to 20 days to respond. As documented in exhibits to the STB petition for rulemaking, some carriers refuse to provide their tariff at all, or provide incomplete versions.
An investigator conducting a shipper review today would need to request the carrier's tariff, wait up to 20 days, and hope to receive a complete and accurate copy. The consumer's estimate could be months old by the time the comparison is possible.
Electronic tariff publication, as proposed in the STB petition, would change this. An investigator conducting a shipper review could compare the consumer's estimate against the carrier's published tariff in real time. The tariff would be publicly accessible, timestamped, and verifiable. No 20-day waiting period. No reliance on the carrier to self-produce the document being used to evaluate its own compliance.
The shipper review tool exists. The complaints exist. The only missing piece is the tariff transparency that would make the reviews efficient and conclusive.
Sources: FMCSA A&I Safety Investigations By Type report, Carrier Type: Household Goods, FY 2022-2026, snapshot 9/25/2026STB petition for rulemaking, Ex. E-149 CFR 1310.5 (tariff availability requirements)FMCSA National Consumer Complaint Database (NCCDB), complaint category analysis