In Every Tariff Dispute That Was Ever Resolved, the Adjudicator Could See the Tariff. HHG Consumers Cannot.
From the Supreme Court to the ICC to the FMC, every published decision on carrier rate reasonableness relied on examining the carrier's tariff. For household goods movers, that tariff is invisible. A petition before the Surface Transportation Board would change that.
A tariff is a carrier's published price list. It contains every rate, charge, and service term the carrier is authorized to use. For more than a century, tariffs have been the foundation of transportation rate regulation. When a shipper disputes a charge, the adjudicator, whether a court, the ICC, the STB, or the FMC, examines the tariff to determine whether the charge was authorized and whether it was reasonable.
This system works. It has produced thousands of published decisions across every mode of transportation. But it only works when someone can see the tariff.
For household goods motor carriers, the tariff is invisible. It is not filed with any agency. It is not published online. Carriers routinely refuse to provide it when consumers ask. The adjudicatory system that resolved rate disputes for railroads, freight carriers, water carriers, and ocean shipping cannot function for household goods movers because the foundational document is inaccessible.
A petition for rulemaking currently pending before the Surface Transportation Board (Household Goods Shippers Coalition, proposed amendments to STB Ex Parte No. 555, 49 CFR Part 1310) would require HHG carriers to publish tariffs electronically, the same way water carriers have been required to since 2019 and ocean shipping carriers since 2024. The legal history of tariff-based adjudication illustrates why this matters.
The Supreme Court: The Tariff IS the Rate
The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that the published tariff is the only lawful rate.
In Maislin Industries v. Primary Steel, Inc. (497 U.S. 116, 1990), the Court held that the ICC cannot permit carriers to deviate from filed tariff rates through negotiated rates. The 'filed rate doctrine' means the tariff is the rate, and carriers cannot charge more or less than what the tariff states. The Court stated that allowing departure from filed rates 'would effectively repeal the filed rate doctrine' and undermine the statutory scheme requiring publication of tariffs.
In Reiter v. Cooper (507 U.S. 258, 1993), the Court recognized that tariff reasonableness is an adjudicable question. When a shipper claims tariff rates are unreasonable, the shipper can raise that defense in court or seek agency adjudication. The tariff is not just a price list but a document subject to legal scrutiny. If the tariff is invisible, the shipper cannot exercise this right.
In ICC v. Transcon Lines (513 U.S. 138, 1995), the Court confirmed the agency can 'consider all the circumstances surrounding an undercharge suit' to determine whether collection of the filed rate would constitute an unreasonable practice. Even after a move is complete, the tariff remains the reference document for determining whether the carrier's charges were lawful.
The ICC Era: A Century of Tariff-Based Adjudication
The Interstate Commerce Commission adjudicated tariff reasonableness disputes from 1887 through 1995. Tariff regulation was extended to motor carriers (including HHG carriers) by the Motor Carrier Act of 1935. The Household Goods Transportation Act of 1980 added criminal sanctions for HHG tariff violations, including 'weight-bumping,' the subject of a 1979 GAO report.
In Household Goods Carriers' Bureau v. ICC (584 F.2d 437, D.C. Cir. 1978), the D.C. Circuit upheld the ICC's authority to regulate HHG tariff provisions, including rate structures, valuation options, and accessorial charges. The court confirmed the ICC's broad authority over the content and reasonableness of HHG carrier tariffs.
In West Coast Truck Lines v. Weyerhaeuser Co. (893 F.2d 1016, 9th Cir. 1990), the Ninth Circuit applied the filed rate doctrine: the tariff rate on file with the ICC is the only lawful rate. The court examined the tariff as the definitive document.
These cases share a common feature: the adjudicator could see the tariff. The tariff was filed with the ICC, published, and available for examination. The ICC decided thousands of tariff reasonableness cases between 1935 and 1995. The system worked because the foundational document was accessible.
The STB: Two HHG Tariff Cases in 25 Years
After ICC termination in 1995, the STB inherited jurisdiction over HHG tariff rules. The STB's tariff regulations (49 CFR Part 1310) have not been amended since 1997. HHG tariffs are no longer filed with any agency. They exist on paper, theoretically 'available for inspection' on request (49 U.S.C. 13702(c)), with carriers allowed up to 20 days to respond (49 CFR 1310.5).
The STB has adjudicated exactly two HHG tariff reasonableness cases since 1995:
Nancy Hall v. Aloha International Moving Services (STB Docket No. 42048, final decision March 9, 2001): A federal court referred tariff and rate reasonableness questions to the STB for a Hawaii-to-Minnesota HHG move. The STB accepted jurisdiction, reviewed the carrier's tariff, and issued a decision. The consumer did not prevail on the rate question, but the system functioned: the Board took the case, applied its tariff expertise, and resolved the questions the court could not.
John Vetne v. Home & Office Movers (STB Docket No. NOR 42182, settled December 12, 2024): The first HHG shipper complaint filed with the STB in approximately 25 years. Filed under 49 U.S.C. 13701-13702 for adjudication of rate reasonableness. The carrier settled for $6,500 rather than defend its tariff charges before the Board.
Two cases in 25 years. Not because HHG tariff disputes are rare (they are the number one consumer complaint category), but because consumers cannot access the tariff to identify whether a dispute exists.
The FMC: Where Electronic Tariffs Work Right Now
The Federal Maritime Commission regulates international household goods shipping under the Shipping Act. The FMC required electronic tariff publication in 2024 (89 FR 25, January 2, 2024). The result is a functioning system that the STB petition asks to replicate for domestic HHG carriers.
In FMC Docket 2025(I) (2025), an ALJ examined whether a common carrier 'established, observed and enforced tariffs showing all rates, charges, classifications, rules, and practices in an automated tariff system.' The electronically published tariff was the evidentiary foundation. The ALJ could compare the carrier's charges against its published rates and make a finding.
In Moses & Jupiter v. Schumacher Cargo Logistics (FMC Docket 2046(I)), consumers shipped household goods from the United States to Trinidad and Tobago and sought $22,299 in reparations for overcharges. The FMC ALJ examined the carrier's tariff to determine whether the charges were authorized.
In Dukart v. Ocean Star International (FMC Docket 20-03), household goods shipped from Denver to Belize. The complainant alleged Shipping Act violations. The FMC examined tariff compliance.
The FMC publishes its decisions in bound law reporter volumes. Volume 8 (2025) contains the most recent tariff and Shipping Act decisions. The existence of a published law reporter demonstrates the volume and sophistication of tariff-based adjudication that electronic publication enables.
The FMC's system works because the tariff is published, findable, and examinable. The STB's system for HHG carriers does not work because the tariff is none of these things.
The Documented Refusals
If HHG tariffs were merely difficult to access, the problem would be inconvenient. But carriers actively refuse to provide them.
In Vetne v. Eagle Moving Group (FMCSA-2026-0069, the first 14704(c) complaint filed with the Secretary of Transportation), the complainant requested the carrier's tariff. The broker refused to provide it.
In Griffin v. Menards Moving & Storage (FMCSA-2026-2971), the complainant requested the tariff and the broker-carrier agreement under 49 CFR 371.109 and 371.115. Menards refused to provide either document.
Noble Moving responded to a tariff request on March 9, 2026: 'Please be advised that our internal tariff listing is not provided to clients.'
Three documented refusals from three different companies. The tariff that is supposed to be 'available for inspection' upon request is treated as a proprietary internal document. Electronic publication eliminates the request barrier entirely.
What This History Shows
Every published decision on carrier rate reasonableness, from the Supreme Court to the ICC to the STB to the FMC, relied on examining the carrier's tariff. The tariff was the evidentiary foundation in every case.
For HHG motor carriers, that foundation does not exist in practice. The tariff is not filed, not published, not accessible, and actively withheld. The result: two STB adjudications in 25 years, despite HHG pricing disputes being the number one consumer complaint category at FMCSA (Estimates/Final Charges leads every year).
The FMC demonstrated in 2024 that electronic tariff publication is feasible, affordable, and effective for household goods shipping. The STB demonstrated in 2019 that electronic tariff publication works for water carriers. The pending STB petition asks for the same requirement for HHG motor carriers.
The legal history is clear: tariff-based adjudication works when the tariff is accessible. It cannot work when the tariff is invisible. Electronic publication is the fix.
Data
Tariff-Based Adjudication Across Transportation Modes
| Forum | Mode | Tariff Accessible? | Published Decisions | System Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ICC (1887-1995) | Rail, motor carriers | Yes (filed with ICC) | Thousands | Functioned for a century |
| Supreme Court | All modes | Yes (filed rate doctrine) | Maislin, Reiter, Transcon | Tariff = the only lawful rate |
| FMC (current) | Ocean shipping, int'l HHG | Yes (electronic since 2024) | Ongoing (Vol. 8 published 2025) | Functioning system |
| STB (water carriers) | Water carriers | Yes (electronic since 2019) | Ongoing | Functioning system |
| STB (HHG carriers) | Domestic HHG | No (not filed, not published) | 2 cases in 25 years | Non-functional |
| FMCSA (HHG complaints) | Domestic HHG | No (carriers refuse requests) | 7,385 complaints (2026 thru Oct) | Complaints filed, tariff invisible |
Source:
Companies Mentioned
Sources: Maislin Industries v. Primary Steel, Inc., 497 U.S. 116 (1990).Reiter v. Cooper, 507 U.S. 258 (1993).ICC v. Transcon Lines, 513 U.S. 138 (1995).Household Goods Carriers' Bureau v. ICC, 584 F.2d 437 (D.C. Cir. 1978).West Coast Truck Lines v. Weyerhaeuser Co., 893 F.2d 1016 (9th Cir. 1990).Nancy Hall v. Aloha International Moving Services, STB Docket No. 42048 (March 9, 2001).John Vetne v. Home & Office Movers, STB Docket No. NOR 42182 (settled Dec. 12, 2024).FMC electronic tariff requirement, 89 FR 25 (Jan. 2, 2024).STB water carrier electronic tariff rule, 84 FR 20292 (May 9, 2019).FMC Docket 2025(I), 2046(I), 20-03 (initial decisions available at fmc.gov/readingroom).FMC Decisions, Second Series, Volume 8 (2025).STB petition for rulemaking: Household Goods Shippers Coalition, proposed amendments to Ex Parte No. 555, 49 CFR Part 1310 (December 2026).