States That Regulate Movers Have Fewer Complaints. Here's the Data.
FMCSA complaint data shows a stark divide: states with dedicated household goods regulators see complaint rates 5 to 10 times lower than states without them.
The moving industry is regulated at the federal level by FMCSA for interstate moves. But intrastate moves, the ones that happen within a single state, are governed by a patchwork of state-level rules. Some states have dedicated public utility commissions that actively regulate household goods carriers. Others have essentially no dedicated oversight at all.
The question is whether that difference matters. The answer, based on NCCDB complaint data aggregated across thousands of carriers, is unambiguous: it does. States with dedicated HHG regulation consistently show complaint rates per company that are a fraction of what unregulated states produce. The gap is not marginal. It is 5x to 20x in some comparisons.
States That Regulate: What They Require and What It Produces
Four states illustrate what active regulation looks like in practice.
Pennsylvania's Public Utility Commission regulates intrastate movers directly. Carriers must hold PUC authority, maintain specific insurance thresholds, and operate under rate structures the commission oversees. With 821 registered companies and 103 NCCDB complaints, PA produces a complaint rate of 0.13 per company. That is the lowest in this dataset.
Ohio's Public Utilities Commission similarly regulates intrastate household goods carriers. The state requires operating certificates, insurance filings, and periodic compliance checks. Ohio has 681 companies and 95 complaints, yielding a rate of 0.14 per company, nearly identical to Pennsylvania.
Washington State's Utilities and Transportation Commission goes further than most. Tariff 15-C requires movers to perform a visual inspection of the shipment before quoting. It sets maximum rates and mandates specific disclosure requirements. With 511 companies and 88 complaints, Washington's rate is 0.17 per company. The visual inspection requirement is particularly significant because estimate fraud, the practice of quoting low sight-unseen and then inflating the price on moving day, is the single most common complaint category nationwide.
North Carolina's Utilities Commission requires certificates and insurance for intrastate carriers. NC has 822 companies and 361 complaints, producing a rate of 0.44 per company. That is higher than the other three regulated states but still well below every unregulated state in our comparison. NC's higher rate may reflect a larger proportion of long-distance brokers operating within the state, but the regulatory framework still produces measurably better outcomes than no framework at all.
States Without Regulation: What Happens
The contrast is severe.
Florida has 2,593 registered moving companies and 7,188 NCCDB complaints. That is a rate of 2.77 complaints per company, more than 21 times Pennsylvania's rate. Florida has no dedicated household goods regulator. The state Attorney General handles enforcement on a case-by-case basis, which in practice means enforcement happens after significant consumer harm has already occurred, if it happens at all. Florida is also the epicenter of the moving broker industry, where companies sell estimates they have no intention of honoring and dispatch the job to the lowest-bidding carrier.
New Jersey has 1,259 companies and 1,911 complaints, a rate of 1.52 per company. NJ has no dedicated HHG regulator. The Garfield, NJ corridor alone accounts for a disproportionate share of consumer complaints nationally, driven by a cluster of broker operations that have been documented extensively in federal docket records.
Nevada, with 254 companies and 331 complaints, produces a rate of 1.30 per company. No dedicated regulator exists. The Las Vegas market in particular generates a high volume of complaints relative to its size.
Indiana has 424 companies and 437 complaints, a rate of 1.03 per company. Some of this is inflated by van line corporate headquarters being domiciled in Indiana (United Van Lines, Mayflower, Atlas, North American), which concentrates complaint filings. But even accounting for that, the rate is significantly higher than any regulated state.
Missouri has 424 companies and 337 complaints, a rate of 0.79 per company. No dedicated regulator. Missouri sits at the lower end of the unregulated group but still produces a rate nearly 6 times that of Pennsylvania.
The Data Side by Side
The comparison becomes most clear when you line up the numbers directly.
The average complaint rate across the four regulated states is 0.22 complaints per company. The average across the five unregulated states is 1.48 complaints per company. That is a 6.7x difference.
Even comparing the worst regulated state (North Carolina at 0.44) against the best unregulated state (Missouri at 0.79), the regulated state still outperforms by nearly half. And comparing the best regulated state (Pennsylvania at 0.13) against the worst unregulated state (Florida at 2.77), the gap is over 21x.
This is not a small sample. The dataset covers 7,988 companies and 10,851 complaints across nine states. The pattern holds regardless of which specific states you compare: regulation correlates with dramatically lower complaint rates.
What This Means for Reform
The data points to an obvious conclusion: dedicated state-level HHG regulation works. The states that require it see fewer complaints per company by a wide margin. The mechanism is not mysterious. Licensing requirements filter out undercapitalized operators. Rate oversight prevents the most egregious bait-and-switch pricing. Visual inspection mandates (like Washington's Tariff 15-C) attack estimate fraud at the point of origin.
California's Bureau of Household Goods and Services (BHGS) represents something close to a gold standard. BHGS requires state-specific licensing for intrastate movers, conducts proactive enforcement actions, and maintains a consumer complaint system with real investigative teeth. California's regulatory model demonstrates that states can build effective oversight without waiting for federal action.
At the federal level, the Surface Transportation Board (STB) has an open tariff petition that could reimpose rate regulation on interstate household goods carriers, something that was removed during deregulation in the 1990s. The state-level data in this analysis provides a direct evidence base for that petition: where rate and licensing regulation exist, complaint rates drop.
The policy implication is straightforward. States without dedicated HHG oversight should create it. The PUC model used by Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Washington has decades of track record. The data confirms what those states already know: regulation reduces consumer harm in the moving industry by a measurable, significant, and consistent margin.
Complaints per Company by State
Regulated states (green) vs. unregulated states (red)
Source: FMCSA NCCDB, Trunk Research
Regulation Impact
0.22 per company
Avg regulated rate
1.48 per company
Avg unregulated rate
PA vs FL: 21x difference
Worst gap
Source: FMCSA NCCDB, Trunk Research
Data
Complaint Rates: Regulated vs. Unregulated States
| State | Regulation Status | Companies | NCCDB Complaints | Complaints per Company |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pennsylvania | Regulated (PUC) | 821 | 103 | 0.13 |
| Ohio | Regulated (PUCO) | 681 | 95 | 0.14 |
| Washington | Regulated (UTC) | 511 | 88 | 0.17 |
| North Carolina | Regulated (Utilities Commission) | 822 | 361 | 0.44 |
| Missouri | Unregulated | 424 | 337 | 0.79 |
| Indiana | Unregulated | 424 | 437 | 1.03 |
| Nevada | Unregulated | 254 | 331 | 1.30 |
| New Jersey | Unregulated | 1,259 | 1,911 | 1.52 |
| Florida | Unregulated | 2,593 | 7,188 | 2.77 |
Source: FMCSA NCCDB data aggregated by Trunk, November 2026
What Regulated States Require of Intrastate Movers
| State | Regulatory Body | Key Requirements |
|---|---|---|
| Pennsylvania | PA Public Utility Commission | PUC operating authority, insurance filings, rate structure oversight |
| Ohio | OH Public Utilities Commission | Operating certificates, insurance filings, compliance checks |
| Washington | WA Utilities and Transportation Commission | Tariff 15-C: visual inspection before quoting, maximum rate schedules, disclosure mandates |
| North Carolina | NC Utilities Commission | Certificates of authority, insurance requirements for intrastate carriers |
Source: State regulatory agency websites
Companies Mentioned
Sources: FMCSA NCCDB data aggregated by Trunk. State regulatory agency websites (PA PUC, OH PUCO, WA UTC, NC Utilities Commission, CA BHGS). Trunk state NCCDB complaint analyses.