FMCSA Maintains a Top 100 List of the Worst Movers. It Doesn't Use It.
FMCSA's own enforcement manual describes a system for identifying and investigating the worst household goods carriers and brokers. The agency compiled the lists, refreshed them monthly, and then closed zero enforcement cases in FY 2026.
FMCSA's Commercial Enforcement and Investigations Division maintains two internal watchlists: a "Top 100 HHG Carrier List" and a "Top 100 Broker List." These lists are compiled from NCCDB complaint data and SMS safety scores, refreshed every 30 days, and described in the agency's own enforcement manual as the primary driver of investigations.
The manual is specific: "Investigations will be driven by the analysis of the Top 100 Lists."
In FY 2026, with both lists actively maintained, FMCSA closed zero HHG carrier enforcement cases. The agency built the system to identify the worst actors in the moving industry. It identified them. Then it did nothing.
What the Top 100 Lists Are
The eFOTM (electronic Field Operations Training Manual) Chapter 4, revised October 2026, describes the Top 100 lists as FMCSA's primary enforcement tool for the household goods moving industry.
The lists rank carriers and brokers by a combination of NCCDB complaint volume and SMS (Safety Measurement System) safety scores. They are maintained by the Commercial Enforcement and Investigations Division and refreshed on a 30-day cycle.
Companies that appear near the top of the carrier list by complaint count include:
- Safe Ship: 321 complaints - Amerisafe: 293 complaints - Menards: 290 complaints - Coastal: 229 complaints - American Van Lines: 215 complaints - Howards: 206 complaints - Value Added: 181 complaints
These are not obscure companies. They are the most-complained-about movers in the federal database.
What Should Trigger Investigations
The eFOTM manual lists specific triggers that should initiate an HHG investigation:
1. High volume of NCCDB complaints 2. Appearance on the Top 100 lists 3. Hostage load reports (carrier refuses to deliver until consumer pays inflated price) 4. Congressional inquiries 5. Media interest or coverage
The manual describes these as action triggers, not informational categories. When a company meets one or more of these criteria, the manual instructs investigators to open a case.
Here is what documented cases look like when measured against the manual's own triggers:
| Trigger | Manual Says | Documented Reality | |---|---|---| | High NCCDB complaints | Opens investigation | Companies with 200+ complaints remain uninvestigated | | Top 100 list appearance | "Investigations will be driven by" these lists | Zero enforcement cases closed in FY 2026 | | Hostage loads | Investigation trigger | Hostage load compensation policy cancelled in 2020 | | Congressional interest | Investigation trigger | Congressional letters have not produced enforcement actions | | Media coverage | Investigation trigger | Companies covered by journalists continue operating unchanged |
Every company documented on Trunk with a complaint history meets at least one of these triggers. Most meet all of them.
What Actually Happened: Zero Enforcement
In FY 2026, FMCSA closed zero HHG carrier enforcement cases. Not a reduced number. Zero.
This is not a single bad year. FMCSA has conducted zero new entrant HHG safety audits for five consecutive fiscal years, from FY 2022 through FY 2026. New entrant audits are the mechanism by which FMCSA is supposed to verify that newly authorized carriers are operating legally before they handle consumer shipments.
The enforcement manual exists. The Top 100 lists exist and are refreshed monthly. The triggers are documented. The complaint data is collected. The entire pipeline from identification to investigation is described in writing.
The pipeline ends at the description. No cases are opened. No investigations are completed. No enforcement actions are taken.
What This Means
FMCSA's enforcement manual is not a proposal or a wish list. It is the agency's own description of how it is supposed to operate. The manual was revised as recently as October 2026, meaning someone at FMCSA updated the document describing an enforcement system that the agency is not using.
The Top 100 lists represent the agency's own determination of which companies pose the greatest risk to consumers. The lists are compiled from the agency's own data. The investigation triggers are written in the agency's own manual. The result is the agency's own inaction.
For consumers, this means the federal complaint system functions as a data collection exercise with no enforcement consequence. Filing a complaint adds your experience to the NCCDB, which adds your mover's complaint count toward the Top 100 list, which triggers nothing.
For the companies on the Top 100 list, the message is clear: appearing on FMCSA's worst-offender list carries no operational risk. The list exists. It is refreshed. It is not enforced.
Companies Mentioned
Sources: FMCSA eFOTM HHG Manual Version 10.2 (October 2026 revision), Chapter 4. FMCSA Analysis and Information (A&I) enforcement case data, FY 2022-2026. Trunk NCCDB complaint analysis.